A
ALTIUS CMFacade · Roofing · Construction Mgmt
ROOFING

Modified Bitumen Roofing: SBS vs APP, and Torch vs Cold vs Self-Adhered

Published November 8, 2026

Four common ways to attach a modified bitumen sheetFour cards. Torch-applied: heated with a hand-held propane torch to adhere. Cold adhesive: low-solvent cold adhesives have virtually no odor. Self-adhered: a membrane with factory adhesive on the back. Hot asphalt: mopped asphalt with the sheet pressed in. The exact method still depends on the product data sheet.Four common ways to attach asheetTorch-appliedheated with a hand-held propanetorch to adhereCold adhesivelow-solvent cold adhesives havevirtually no odorSelf-adhereda membrane with factory adhesive onthe backHot asphaltmopped asphalt with the sheetpressed inThe exact method still depends onthe product data sheet
Four common ways to attach a sheet. Torch-applied: heated with a hand-held propane torch to adhere. Cold adhesive: low-solvent cold adhesives have virtually no odor. Self-adhered: a membrane with factory adhesive on the back. Hot asphalt: mopped asphalt with the sheet pressed in. The exact method still depends on the product data sheet.

What is the difference between SBS and APP modified bitumen?

SBS and APP name the polymer blended into the asphalt: styrene butadiene styrene, which ASTM calls a thermoplastic elastomer, or atactic polypropylene.

ASTM splits them into separate material standards. ASTM D6162 covers SBS sheets reinforced with polyester fabric and glass fiber. ASTM D6222 covers APP sheets with polyester reinforcement.

Those ASTM standards are material specs only. They say suitability of a given roof construction and application techniques are outside their scope, along with fire resistance, field strength, uplift and compatibility.

The manufacturers also separate the two families in their specs. JM says SBS goes down in hot asphalt or cold adhesive, with some products also heat welded. JM says APP goes down by heat welding or, for select products, in cold adhesive.

Siplast says it found in the 1960s that modifying asphalt with SBS produced an elastomeric blend with strong elongation and recovery across a wide range of temperatures. That is the manufacturer’s claim, not a code rule.

What are the application methods?

There are four common ways to attach a sheet. The exact method still depends on the product data sheet.

  • Torch-applied. Siplast says SBS sheets are rolled out and heated with a hand-held propane torch to adhere. JM calls the same approach heat welding and gives a roll-surface target of about 330°F, noting that smoke means the material is overheating.
  • Cold adhesive. Siplast says low-solvent cold adhesives have virtually no odor, which allows reroofing in occupied buildings. JM warns that traditional cutback mastics, with their high solvent content, can soften APP sheets, cause blisters and strip granules, and sells its own MBR cold application adhesive for APP.
  • Self-adhered. A membrane with factory adhesive on the back. Siplast’s Paradiene 20 TS SA has self-adhesive stripes that bond 50 percent of the sheet’s surface area, and it is designed for direct application to approved insulation and roof boards.
  • Hot asphalt. Mopped asphalt with the sheet pressed in. JM says its SBS products may be installed this way and that APP products must never be adhered with hot asphalt.

Some products are narrower than the category suggests. Soprema says its Sopralene FLAM 180 is an SBS sheet that “must be applied only by heat welding or torch-on techniques,” and hot bitumen must not be used. Read the data sheet for the exact product.

Why does NYC treat torch roofing differently?

Because of fire history and a specific rule set.

FDNY’s G-60 study material, revised January 2026, recounts a May 10, 1999 fire in which a roofing crew using propane torches to install modified roofing started a three-alarm fire that destroyed 30 apartments in Manhattan. FDNY says that event led to the torch rules now in the Fire Code.

Here is what FDNY’s materials say now:

  • Permit. A permit is required for “use of any open flame in a torch-applied roofing system.”
  • Operator. Torch work must be personally done by a Certificate of Fitness holder; for LPG or CNG torch operation on torch-applied roofs without oxygen, that is a G-41, G-42 or G-60.
  • Fire guard. An F-60 fire guard must be on continuous duty during torch operations on a roof, and every torch operator must have a fire watch. One guard may cover more than one torch on the same level if each is within 50 feet. Additional guards are required on floors below when sparks and slag could reach them.
  • Combustible roofs. It is illegal to install roofing with a torch on a roof of combustible construction.
  • Occupied roofs. Using LPG on an occupied roof requires an affidavit from a licensed architect or engineer stating the roof is constructed of noncombustible material.
  • Extinguisher. Roofing operations with heat-producing systems need at least one 3-A 40-B:C multi-purpose extinguisher.

FDNY’s F-60 page confirms that the fire watch for torch operations on any rooftop must be conducted by F-60 fire guards.

Permits are issued by FDNY, so confirm current requirements with FDNY before scheduling any torch work. The practical effect is that a torch-down roof in New York carries fire-watch labor, permits and a restriction on deck type that cold-applied and self-adhered systems do not.

What does the NYC Building Code require of modified bitumen?

BC 1507.11 requires a slope designed and built for positive roof drainage. It also requires modified bitumen roof coverings to comply with CGSB 37-GP-56M or ASTM D6162, D6163, D6164, D6222, D6223, D6298 or D6509.

The product sheet should name that standard. Siplast’s SBS lines cite D6163 for fiberglass, D6164 for polyester and D6162 for composite reinforcement.

Chapter 15 adds finish requirements. BC 1504.9 requires reflectance of at least 0.7 initial solar reflectance with 0.75 emittance, or an SRI of 82, on roofs of 2:12 slope or less. BC 1504.8 bars gravel or crushed stone as surfacing.

JM says smooth-surfaced APP sheets must be coated with a JM-approved coating. Whatever the cap sheet, confirm how the finished surface will meet the reflectance rule. Our flat roof systems comparison lists the other common requirements.

How should an owner choose among them?

Start with the building, not the sheet.

  1. Deck. Combustible or noncombustible decks decide whether a torch is even legal.
  2. Occupancy. Occupied buildings favor cold adhesive or self-adhered methods, since Siplast says low-solvent cold adhesives have virtually no odor and self-adhesive membranes need no torch.
  3. Drainage. JM states that areas where water ponds for more than 24 hours are unacceptable and ineligible for its Peak Advantage Guarantee, so fix slope before choosing the membrane. The drains and ponding guide explains why.
  4. Details. JM sells PMMA as a flashing detail over SBS and BUR membranes, as covered in our PMMA explainer.
  5. Warranty. Installation method affects which warranty options apply, so read the manufacturer’s terms before bidding. See roof warranties explained.

Altius CM installs systems from Johns Manville, Siplast and Soprema, and this page describes what their published documents say. It does not mean any of those manufacturers has approved or endorsed Altius CM. For the replacement decision itself, start with replace, recover or restore and our roof repair and replacement service.

Sources

Last verified: November 8, 2026. This is general information, not legal advice or an engineering opinion. Torch permits, certificates and fire-watch rules are set by FDNY and can change; confirm with FDNY and your registered design professional before work starts.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between SBS and APP modified bitumen?

The modifier. ASTM D6162 covers sheets that use styrene butadiene styrene (SBS) thermoplastic elastomer as the primary modifier, and ASTM D6222 covers sheets that use atactic polypropylene (APP) as the primary modifier with polyester reinforcement. Both are material specifications only: ASTM states that application techniques and in-place performance such as fire resistance and wind uplift are outside their scope.

How are modified bitumen sheets installed?

Siplast lists four methods for SBS sheets: torch-applied, cold adhesive, self-adhesive and hot asphalt. Johns Manville says its SBS membranes go down in hot asphalt or cold adhesive, with some products also heat welded, while its APP membranes are heat welded or, for select products, set in cold adhesive. JM states APP products must never be adhered with hot asphalt.

Is torch-applied roofing allowed in New York City?

Yes, under conditions. FDNY study material states that any open flame in a torch-applied roofing system requires an FDNY permit, that the torch work must be personally done by a Certificate of Fitness holder, and that an F-60 fire guard must be on continuous duty during torch operations on a roof. It is illegal to torch on a roof of combustible construction.

Do you need a fire guard when torching a roof in NYC?

Yes. FDNY's F-60 certificate page says the fire watch for torch operations on any rooftop, or in connection with any torch-applied roofing system operation, must be conducted by F-60 fire guards. FDNY's study material adds that one guard may cover more than one torch on the same level if each is within 50 feet, and that additional guards are needed on floors below where sparks and slag could travel.

Can modified bitumen be installed without a torch?

Yes. Siplast describes cold adhesive systems and self-adhesive membranes as methods that avoid the torch, and says low-solvent cold adhesives have virtually no odor, which allows reroofing in occupied buildings such as schools, hospitals and offices. JM and Siplast both publish cold-adhesive specifications and Siplast publishes self-adhesive membranes, but individual products are approved for specific methods, so check the data sheet.

Does modified bitumen have to be code-listed in NYC?

BC 1507.11 requires a slope designed and built for positive drainage and requires modified bitumen roof coverings to comply with CGSB 37-GP-56M or one of ASTM D6162, D6163, D6164, D6222, D6223, D6298 or D6509. Separate Chapter 15 rules on reflectance, impact resistance and edge securement also apply to the finished roof.

Need roof work scoped?

Contact Altius CM